Les politiciens français veulent ajouter une règle de gag à la vaste proposition de discours de haine en ligne du paysaoût 10, 2019
One of the arguments against hate-speech laws is that once the state starts dividing expression into « allowed » and « prohibited, » the « prohibited » category tends to grow, in three ways: first, because company lawyers and other veto-wielders err on the side of caution by excising anything that might be in the « prohibited » bucket; second, because courts respond to these shifts in the discourse by finding more and more edge-cases to be in violation of the law; and finally, because lawmakers are tempted to shovel any speech they or their campaign donors don’t like into the « prohibited » bucket.
These effects are even more pronounced when it comes to online speech regulation: the boiler-rooms full of traumatized moderators working for the Big Tech platforms are already juggling a massive list of internal policies about what can and can’t be said; add to that a set of high-stakes legal consequences for getting it wrong and they begin to err on the side of caution so aggressively that they block messages from people who were the targets of hate speech. Smaller forums who can’t afford moderation teams are even worse off, using fewer resources to make these calls and unable to afford the legal penalties if they get it wrong.
To watch this in action, have a look at France’s proposed « hate speech » laws, which require platforms to remove any « hateful content » within 24 hours; as this rule has progressed through the French legislature, politicians have perceived an opportunity to add all kinds of dubious ideas and sentiments to the nebulous « hateful content » category, introducing a flood of amendments to the bill.
One such amendment, introduced by « Mr. Le Fur, Mr. Abad, Mr. Bazin, Mr. Brun, Mr. Cinieri, Mr. Cordier, Mr. Pierre-Henri Dumont, Mr. Hetzel, Mr. Kamardine, Mr. Perrut, Mr. Quentin, Mr. Sermier and M. Viala » expands the definition of « hateful content » to include « stigmatizing agricultural activities, breeding or sale of products from agriculture and livestock breeding and inciting acts of intrusion or violence vis-à-vis professionals of agriculture, livestock breeding and the processing and sale of products from these sectors. »
This is functionally indistinguishable from the Ag-Gag laws passed by various US state legislatures, which are used to criminalize animal rights activists who document unsanitary and inhumane conditions in agricultural enterprises. French law already criminalizes breaking and entering and death threats, so the only thing this amendment ads is an obligation on online platforms to censor anything that puts the industry in a bad light.
— marc rees (@reesmarc) July 1, 2019
Facebook has lost a procedural appeal related to a 2015 Illinois class-action lawsuit over the company’s use of facial recognition data, and now it could be on the hook for billions in damages.
As New York State’s shareholder suit against Big Oil for climate denial proceeds, Exxonmobil caught intimidating witnesses
In 2015, a deep investigative report from Inside Climate News revealed that as early as 1977, Exxonmobil knew that it was destroying the planet with CO2 emissions, and its response to that fact was to gin up a decades-long disinformation campaign aimed at sowing expensive doubt about the subject, even as it grew more certain […]
Christopher Brown is a lawyer and science fiction writer; his debut, 2017’s Tropic of Kansas, was an outstanding novel of authoritarianism and resistance, and his next book, Rule of Capture (out on Monday, watch for my review!) is a legal thriller about disaster capitalism, climate catastrophe, and hard-fought political change.
Company executives typically know two things about the cloud: They need to be on it, and they need it to work smoothly. Which means that if you know your way around Google Cloud, you’re going to have employers that want you to lead them through. The Complete Google Cloud Mastery Bundle is just the online […]
In the market for a workhorse laptop for the upcoming school year? Refurbished gear is the way to go. Here are some of our favorite deals on like-new laptop rigs and PCs. Lenovo N22 11.6″ Chromebook 16GB Black (Certified Refurbished) This rig is great for working at home or away, with a 14-hour battery life […]
Cloud storage isn’t just for big businesses. If you’ve got more pictures, videos or work files than your device can handle (and who doesn’t?), then the cloud is where it needs to be. Luckily, there are more options for you than just Dropbox these days. Here’s a roundup of some newer services that can help […]